Sunday, August 28, 2005
Thomson Medical - A Case Study
- 20-Nov-05 : Added in FY05 Results (Released on 27-Oct-05)
- 24-Sep-05 : Thomson share price hit $0.205 on 22-Sep, the first time it closed above $0.20 since Feb-05. It has hit my first tgt which I had previously planned to sell some of my hldgs when I first did this study. Now, after looking at the other healthcare stocks which have hospital operations like Parkway, Raffles Medical and even loss-making HMI being traded at a premium to NAV, I have decided not to sell till the FY05 results are announced or if share price goes above NAV of $0.25. I don't expect any negative surprises and if results are good, I may even consider to hold for longer term. Note that prices may drop again in the coming weeks as it had gone up a bit too fast (aro' 10%) fm $0.185.
Background (Not Updated)
Thomson Medical had been trading below its IPO price of $0.22 since listing in 26-Jan-05. I wanted to apply for the IPO but good thing I missed it as I was busy then. I bought my first lots in Mar-05 when we were expecting our 2nd kid and was visiting Thomson regularly for check-ups. It's always very crowded and the waiting time so long, so I assume biz must be very good. Also, a lot of publicity aro' then due to Zoe Tay delivering there.
Recently, after my studies on HMI, I have been accumulating Thomson Medical shares. Now, a full study to justify my purchases :D
Financial Data
All the data in this case study are extracted fm the Thomson Medical 2004 Annual Report. Some of the figures in the fllwg table are extracted fm the periodical "Shares Investment",
Thomson Medical | 2001 | 2002 | 2003 | 1H04 | 2004 | 1H05 | 2005 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Margin (%) | NA | 1.35 | NA | ----- | 12.66 | 15.58 | ? |
ROE (%) | ----- | ----- | -30.82 | ----- | 7.90 | ----- | ? |
DIV (S$) | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | ----- | 0.01 |
EPS (S$) | Pre-List | Pre-List | -3.15 | 0.0125 | 0.0198 | 0.0133 | 0.0224 |
Turnover (S$M) | 30.773 | 31.160 | 31.837 | 17.787 | 36.378 | 19.040 | 41.176 |
Cash + Bank Bal (S$M) | ? | ? | 5.813 | 7.853 | 9.167 | 11.84 | 10.976 |
Short Term Investment (S$M) | ? | - | - | - | - | - | - |
Current Liabilities - Bank Borrowings (S$M) | ? | ? | 1.836 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 1.36 |
Long Term Bank Borrowings (S$M) | ? | ? | 30.172 | 27.7 | 27.7 | 16.7 | 9.8 |
NAV / Share (S$) | ? | ? | 0.1023 | 0.2501 | 0.2596 | 0.2505 | 0.2656 |
Issued Shares = 264,975,700 @ $0.12 Par ; PE 11.8 @ $0.175
Note :
- NAV for 2004 and 2003 based on pre-list no. of shares. Would be 19.49cts and 7.68cts if based on post-list.
- EPS for 2004 and 2003 based on pre-list no. of shares. Would be 1.48cts and -2.37cts if based on post-list.
- FY05 is end-Aug
Substantial Hldgs
- T Holdings Pte Ltd : 53,029,200 or 20.01%
- Harilela (Singapore) Private Limited : 44,722,250 or 16.88%
- Cheng Wei Chen, Dr : Direct 30,016,050 or 11.33% ; Deemed 65,577,300 or 24.75%
Lee Siew Chin, Dr : Direct 12,548,100 or 4.74% ; Deemed 83,045,250 or 31.34% - Dr Cheng Wei Chen is the spouse of Dr Lee Siew Chin. Each of them is deemed to be interested in the shares held by each other and both are deemed interested in the shareholdings in T Holdings Pte Ltd.
- Cheng Li Chang, Dr : Direct 3,234,200 or 1.22% ; Deemed 56,263,400 or 21.23%
Yeo Chye Neo Angeline, Dr : Direct 3,234,200 or 1.22% ; Deemed 56,263,400 or 21.23%- Dr Cheng Li Chang is the spouse of Dr Yeo Chye Neo Angeline. Each of them is deemed to be interested in the shares held by each other and both are deemed interested in the shareholdings in T Holdings Pte Ltd.
- Hari Naroomal Harilela, Dr : Direct 1,481,400 or 0.56% ; Deemed 44,722,250 or 16.88%
- Dr Hari Naroomal Harilela is deemed interested in the shareholdings in Harilela (Singapore) Private Limited.
- Free Float : 40.44%
FY 2005 (Extracts)
Revenue
- Increase by 13.2% ($36.4Mil to $41.2Mil)
- Hospital Operations & Ancilliary Services : +11.2% ($30.9Mil to $34.3Mil)
- Due to increase in inpatient admissions
- Specialised & Other Revenue : +24.4% ($5.5Mil to $6.9Mil)
- Due to increase fm Thomson Women's Clinics (3 new clinics)
- Hospital Operations & Ancilliary Services : +11.2% ($30.9Mil to $34.3Mil)
Gross Profit
- Increase by 20.6% ($14.43Mil to $17.4Mil)
- Gross Profit Margin : 39.7% to 42.3%
- Due to better direct materials margins, labour efficiency and reduction in overhead
Net Profit After Tax
- Increase by 35.5% ($3.9Mil to $5.3Mil)
- Due to higher revenue, GPM and lower finance cost (reduced by $18.5Mil fm IPO proceeds and surplus funds)
Mid-Year 2005 (Extracts)
Revenue
- Increase by 7% ($17.8Mil to $19.0Mil)
- Hospital Operations & Ancilliary Services : +5.8% ($$15.3Mil to $16.1Mil)
- Due to increase in inpatient admissions
- Specialised & Other Revenue : +15.5% ($2.5Mil to $2.9Mil)
- Due to increase fm Thomson Women's Clinics (2 new clinics)
- Hospital Operations & Ancilliary Services : +5.8% ($$15.3Mil to $16.1Mil)
Gross Profit
- Increase by 11.7% ($7Mil to $7.9Mil)
- Gross Profit Margin : 39.5% to 41.3%
- Due to better direct materials margins, labour efficiency and reduction in overhead cost
Net Profit After Tax
- Increase by 11.8% ($2.5Mil to $2.8Mil)
- Would have been higher if not for promotional expenses for IPO listing & full depreciation of Millenium Wing
Bank Borrowings
- Decrease from $29.7Mil to $18.7Mil (use IPO proceeds)
Annual Report 2004 (Extracts)
Revenue
In FY2004, total revenue for the Group rose by 1.3% to S$31.3 million. Revenue for FY2004 was mainly contributed from hospital and ancillary services operations. The increased revenue was mainly from higher number of inpatient admissions which increased by 9% compared with FY2003. The Group also recorded a 4.4% increase in the number of deliveries and a 11.1% increase in the number of operating theatre cases over the previous financial year. The revenue contribution from specialised and other services business segment, post acquisition, was S$442,000.
Gross Profit
Our gross profi t increased by $3.0 million (or 30.2%) from $9.8 million in FY2003 to $12.8 million in FY2004. Despite an increase in revenue of 1.3%, cost of sales reduced by 12.1%. Gross margins improved from 31.7% to 40.8%. This was mainly due to lower direct materials and lower direct labour costs. Labour effi ciency improved due to streamlining of procedures and job scope and automation of administrative procedures.
Profi t before Tax
Our profi t before taxation improved by $5.7 million from a loss of $0.9 million in FY2003 to a profi t of $4.8 million in FY2004. Our hospital operations and ancillary services business segment recorded profi t before taxation of $4.6 million for FY2004 as compared to a loss before taxation of $0.9 million for FY2003. The improved performance is due to increased revenue from operations. The specialised and other services business segment recorded, post acquisition, a profi t before taxation of $218,000.
Moving Ahead
The outlook for the healthcare services industry in Singapore is very competitive, with many private and public healthcare services providers in the market. However, the Group is confi dent that it will continue to enjoy a steady stream of patients with its well established relationship with our tenant specialists and supportive accredited specialists. We believe that with our track record of over 25 years and our good working relationship with specialists, we will continue to be one of the preferred healthcare providers for women and children. As one of the leading providers for women and children’s healthcare services, our local growth strategy is to capitalise on the Government’s $300 million pro-family incentives announced in August 2004. We believe there will be a positive outcome with this initiative and we expect birth rates to increase in the coming year. Our other plans include the setting up of additional Thomson Women’s Clinics, extending parentcraft services and implementing new and innovative programs to encourage the use of our hospital’s facilities and services. Regionally, we aim to increase our presence by intensifying marketing efforts at key catchment areas for foreign patients. We will also be exploring opportunities for healthcare consultancy services, hospital management services and seeking out strategic regional partnerships. The Group intends to work closely with the Singapore Tourism Board to market its services to the region, in particular, Indonesia. We will organise road shows, public forums and seminars to showcase our capabilities and competencies with the aim to attract more foreign patients to our hospital.
Comments (Not Updated)
- Improving NAV (from premium to discount)
- IPO : Price $0.22 vs NAV $0.1949 (FY04)
- Now : Price $0.185 vs NAV $0.2505 (mid-yr '05)
- Profitable in 1H05
- EPS is 1.33cts
- If profitability continues to full-year, may declare dividends
- Assuming FY05 EPS is aro' 2cts
- Shld be able to give at least 0.5ct dividend
- => 2.7% Net Yield @ $0.185
- Purchase by Director
- 150,000 shares twice in Jul & Aug
- Either good indication that Thomson is doing well or director averaging down IPO shares :D
Re-designation of COO
- May be bad as it indicates COO didn't perform up to expectations
- May be good if purpose is to improve results in new area
Conclusions (Not Updated)
Be warned, the above has been created to justify my recent additional buy of Thomson Medical shares. This will be intended for mid to long term hold as Thomson Medical looks like a potential good yield stock. Daily trading volume is very low, so it's not recommended for those who may need to sell in the short term as you may not be able to sell at a good price.
My Action (Not Updated)
Decide after FY05 results are out. Most likely sell half my hldgs if it hits above $0.20 for immediate 10% profits. My dream target price is aro' NAV, ie. $0.25. There'll likely be strong resistance at $0.22 (IPO price) as many who got fm IPO will look to exit, given its illiquidity and price drop after IPO. There's also a risk that results may not be up to my expectations. In that case, become long term hold :D
Share Price (Not Updated)
- 1mth : $0.17-$0.19
- 3mth : $0.165-$0.19
- 1yr : $0.165-$0.22
References
- 27-Oct-05 : FY05 Results / Press Release
- 12-Apr-05 : Mid Year FY05 Results
- 31-Jan-05 : FY04 Final Results
- Annual Report 2004
- IPO Prospectus
- Blog Bullrun / Forum
- Open Mkt Transactions by Director
- 26-May-06 : Buy 174,000 Shares @ $0.3341 by Harilela Hotels (S) Pte Ltd
- 25-Apr-06 : Buy 100,000 Shares @ $0.395 by Harilela Hldgs (S) Pte Ltd
- 21-Apr-06 : Buy 130,000 Shares @ $0.395 by Harilela Hldgs (S) Pte Ltd
- 19-Apr-06 : Buy 274,000 Shares @ $0.395 by Harilela Hldgs (S) Pte Ltd
- 10-Mar-06 : Sell 100,000 Shares @ $0.30 by Phua Wee Thuan
- 9-Mar-06 : Sell 100,000 Shares @ $0.295 by Phua Wee Thuan
- 8-Mar-06 : Sell 100,000 Shares @ $0.2993 by Phua Wee Thuan
- 6-Mar-06 : Sell 200,000 Shares @ $0.305 by Phua Wee Thuan
- 24-Feb-06 : Sell 50,000 Shares @ $0.315 by Phua Wee Thuan
- 24-Feb-06 : Sell 50,000 Shares @ $0.31 by Phua Wee Thuan
- 21-Feb-06 : Sell 50,000 Shares @ $0.305 by Phua Wee Thuan
- 17-Feb-06 : Sell 50,000 Shares @ $0.295 by Phua Wee Thuan
- 13-Feb-06 : Sell 50,000 Shares @ $0.30 by Phua Wee Thuan
- 17-Nov-05 : Buy 45,000 Shares by Phua Wee Thuan
- 2-Nov-05 : Buy 245,000 Shares by Angeline Yeo Chye Neo (Wife of Cheng Li Chang)
- 31-Oct-05 : Buy 100,000 Shares by Phua Wee Thuan
- 15-Aug-05 : Buy 150,000 Shares by Phua Wee Thuan
- 8-Jul-05 : Buy 150,000 Shares by Phua Wee Thuan
- Others
Disclaimer : Use the above at your own risk! We'll not be responsible for any losses incurred but you can give us credit if you make money :D